Exactly as extreme proof of incest would be perceived inside Queen Lear, so can also multiple outlines of your own Cinderella folktale. Indeed, the newest seem to discussed like-attempt at the beginning of the fresh new gamble has been thought to be tale kind of 923, "Love Such as for example Salt." Inside the 1886 Age. S. Hartland labeled the original off just what the guy think was four distinguishable variety of "The brand new Outcast Child" since "King Lear particular" (310), plus in 1893 Marian Cox referred to the first elements of Cap o' Rushes (a version of Cinderella tale) while the "King Lear View -- Enjoying Including Salt" (xxv, 80). The folktale usually comes to an end into the relationships of the daughter so you can a good prince -- just as Christabel fundamentally marries their prince, according to Coleridge's visible agreements having finishing their incomplete ballad.(7)
Whereas Cox categorized "King Lear View -- Loving Such Salt" to the Cap o' Rushes story method of, Anna Rooth categorized the story on Catskin facts type of (14-fifteen, 19-20) -- plus according to the exact same spot schema mentioned above. Within the Rooth's examination of the new Cinderella legend this group of Limit o' Rushes and you will Catskin stories represents the new Aarne-Thompson class "The dress regarding Gold, out of Silver, as well as Celebrities" (Aarne and Thompson 82). Within Catskin and you can Cap o' Rushes tales the only real differentiating factors involve the appearance of the new "King Lear View" in addition to "Outcast Woman" during the Cap o' Rushes. " Predicated on Alan Dundes, "That is off tremendous advantages from inside the seeking see Queen Lear" (234). With the spot writeup on "The dress away from Gold, away from Gold, as well as Celebrities," which has each other Catskin and you will Cover o' Rushes facets, begins the following: "Establish of your dad who would like to get married his very own daughter." And also the dominant motifs about facts are such: (1) a great deathbed promise concerning the 2nd spouse; (2) good lecherous father; (3) a dad exactly who casts their daughter forward whenever she will not wed him; and you will (4) new flight of one's maiden to escape relationship. "The gist of all that it," claims Dundes, "is that the 'love for example salt, spot appears to be a weakened style of the new folktale area where a great `mad' dad attempts to wed his personal child" (234).
Because of the has an effect on into Queen Lear from these individuals areas of the Cinderella story, Dundes asserts that enjoy should-be comprehend in the daughter's perspective -- perhaps not the latest father's, suggesting hence so it works with "`daughter-father' incest unlike 'father-daughter' incest!" (235). But since Shakespeare entitled the latest play the Catastrophe from Queen Lear and because they concentrates primarily towards the Lear's attention and you may issues, quite the opposite can also be -- and really should -- end up being recommended. And not only provides Freud, Bransom, and you can a host of other Shakespeare experts advised hence, but very likewise has that great progenitor from Shakespeare criticism -- Samuel Taylor Coleridge, which emphasized inside the notes getting a beneficial lecture on the Lear (dated January 28, 1819) that the king are "an element of the subject-case of the fresh new enjoy.(8)
That Coleridge understood inside Queen Lear components of this new cinderella legend as well as incest have a look a bit obvious regarding their crucial reviews on the latest gamble. Which he provided comparable issue during the Christabel looks equally precious. Offered, his really sustained reviews to the Lear did not arise up to their lecture when you look at the January 1819. But he'd said the fresh tragedy regarding the 2nd lecture out-of their 1811-12 collection, in which he commented on the play within better size about fourteenth lecture. In addition, as R. Good. Foakes highlights, Coleridge had read King Lear along with composed a number of annotations on it in two versions regarding Shakespeare -- one to extended annotation being dated January step one, 1813 (5.dos.323). No matter if his remarks and you will annotations took place following composition from Christabel (1797-1800), he had been studying and thinking about Shakespeare apparently and for an eternity -- " day-after-day . since i have is actually a decade dated," as he conveyed in his notes for a good lecture on may 19, 1812(5.step one.429).